Written by Clarke Kent
Justice was alerted that CT, on Sept 7, 2017 was arrested for a code #19.2-306 a violation of probation. It was from a violation that occurred on Aug 31, 2017 and has the case # CR15003242-02. On Aug 31, 2017 a writ was executed to CT for his seizure (arrest) for the purpose of requiring him to answer the courts contention of a violation of probation. He appeared for a hearing on Sept 12, 2017 at which time he made arrangements for time to secure representation by an attorney. Another hearing is set for Sept 26, th 2017. Justice is in the process of attaining more information and will keep our readers up to date on what transpire. We are presently receiving info from sources that will expand on the new information we know for a fact that CT faces 4/5 years in the penitentiary if he violated his arrangement for his probation. More to follow.
Written by Clarke Kent
BB on Oct 19, 2005 sent a post on the Monster Batista Xanga.com weblog. The attached Dedication to my Baby Mary Rachel Carson. It gives a glimpse of BB.
Evidence perks interest in the bus driver who feels that she observed Shellie on Va Beach Blvd prior to her murder. Evidence asks in a comment on the post “HRT Driver Sighting Raises Perplexing Scenario,” post date September 1, 1017 “In relation to the Bus Driver observations. I feel that she may have mistaken the time by the one hour.” Back in Feb 2014 I requested ANON L (Bus driver) to please confirm that she started work at 11 PM instead of 12 AM on Aug 13/Aug14, 2005. I also alerted cold case unit via Det Horvath at the same time of Anon L sighting and sent him a copy of my post “Justice in Pursuit of Now Information, post date Feb 11, 2014. In my last correspondence with ANON L she replied on Feb 12, 2014 to my question of her starting time with Hi Clarke, “I called HRT and the boss wasn’t in so I left a message. No one in dispatch could answer that question.” That was our last conversation as she never contacted me further. I have tried in vain to reach her recently and have had no luck or success even talking with her. Did we have interference from LE would ask her not to talk further with Justice, I do not know. If it was earlier 11:20 -11:25 PM it would fit in with Shellie talking with BB while the white/cream color car followed her home from the 7-Eleven.
The cell phone recorders indicate that Shellie was on the phone with BB via his home phone, not his cell phone. With the understanding now available to us BB could have been not home and had “call forwarding” transferred to his cell phone while he and another followed her home from the 7-Eleven. We know for a fact 2 things. The first is that her father met Shellie at the side door as she enterest her home at 11:49PM on Sat, Aug 13, 2005. We also know that Shellie talked with BB via a call to his home phone from 10:54 PM to 11:49PM. Now if the bus driver was 1 hour late when she observed Shellie was actually 1 hour earlier it would put BB as the driver of the white car following her. Justice could not confirm that that is the reality and the young girl on the bike was someone else. If only there was a way to confirm that the time was actually 1 hour earlier it would put BB in a difficult position. We must deal with reality, however I’m not convinced and it only would prove he lied.
Evidence also asks a question “Was the Bike Rider unaware of the car following her?” In my original post I wrote “She (busdriver) feels that the bike rider (Shellie) was unaware of the car.” Evidence also questions the point of observation and where would rider be coming from? The point of observation was the bus stop on the eastbound Va Beach Blvd prior to Little Neck Rd. Shellie would have taken her bike from the 7/11 via Kings Grant Rd to Va Beach Blvd riding her bike in the west bound Va Beach Blvd making a right turn around 11:25 PM and arriving at her home and greeting her father at11:49 PM, which is a 24 minute ride home
And questions or thoughts?
Written by Clarke Kent
BB and MF relationship is unique for the boyfriend of Shellie. Shellie was manipulative and used BB for his car and her purpose. BB was head over heels in love with her. There had to be some jealousy from B, however Shellie included him in to things BB and her shared and MF was available. The relationship between MF and BB is of interest when you consider the circumstances of MF losing to BB. It’s interesting from both perspectives. I remember that after Shellie brutal murder, both BB and MF went and visited the Carsons immediately. The arrived together. I also remember back 5 years that BB made numerous statements regarding MF so I decided to start rereading the post from beginning and on Post #706 BB answers a question posted by a Shelby who asked him “Did MF walk Shellie as far as the pond or not?” Shelby continues “If not and he said that he did, why would he lie about something like that?” The two important points in BB answer were he defended MF and also revealed that they both stay in touch. I attach the post and answers as an attachment. I recall that we learned just recently that BB, after the reconciliation all [??] MF. I further recall all the other things BB did for MF including driving him along with Shellie to Circuit City when they began the argument/fight the early evening prior to her murder. I also remember it was BB who brought MF to be interviewed and stayed for the interview. There is a link between these two boyfriends of Shellie. Can it point to something involving them in the murder?
Written By Clarke Kent
Justice has been trying to fit known facts into a scenario that indicated the HRT bus driver timeline on her sighting of Shellie. the bus driver known s Anon Linda revealed the following: She was the bus driver known on Va Beach Blvd and because the route requires that she arrive at each pick up location at specific times and therefore was very conscious of time on date of Aug 13/14, 2005. On the evening of Shellie’s murder, she started at 11 PM and was traveling east of Va Beach Blvd. She arrived at one of her appointment pick up spots early and while parked on the east bound side of Va Beach Blvd she observed a single young female riding a bike on the opposite side (VB Blvd) going westbound. As she watched this young lady ride her bike she observed a white sedan medium sized following at a distance. She became transfixed on watching the bike rider and the white sedan. She explained her intense interest was because she was molested at a young girl and some how she sensed possible danger. The time line she observed the young girl was between 12:20 and 12:25AM. She continues that she, the bike rider in the westbound lane she saw a vehicle following had two riders, the driver was taller than the person on the passenger side. She could not see the driver but could only see a smaller image of the passenger. She described the car as white or cream in color and it was following who she believes was Shellie, at a close distance. When prodded she feels that the bike rider (Shellie) was unaware of the car. Anon L continues that the car in the far right lane and for obvious reasons was diving at the same pace as the bike, thereby traveling 15 mph in a 45 mph speed limit on Va Beach Blvd. As the bike passed she watched as she approached Little Neck Rd corner and did observe that the bike rider turned right followed by the medium sized sedan.
The perplexing question is if we assume for research investigation reasons to assume it was Shellie, how do we fit this scenario into the other facts that we know? That is what I’m asking the cadre of sleuths that follow our blog to assist us with there thinking.
These are the facts that are confirmed. Shellie arrived at her house and was greeted by her father at 11:49 PM on Aug 13, 2005,and retired to her room. She had arrived home on her bike and entered the house by the side door. The parents then retired for the evening. She had a 3 minute phone call at 12:53 lasting to 12:56AM. We know that she talked on her cell phone to BB (10:54 to 11:49) 55 minutes to BB home phone arriving home at 11:45 PM that confirms the parents time of her arrival. We know that BB told us he visited her between 12 and 1 AM and they reconciled. We have never confirmed that BB reconciliation actually happened. The question and problem we have is if Anon is correct how do we place her on a bike being on Va Beach Blvd between 12:20/12:25. The only plausible reason I can see is either Anon L was mistaken by 1 hour and Shellie was on Va Beach Blvd at 11:20 – 11:25 which would be very possible or she went home, left immediately and was returning after a visit with someone east of Va beach Blvd and returning home leaving her cell in her bedroom prior to visiting the Seven Eleven.
These are what we absolutely know as facts
A. Conversation ono bike returning from 7-11 at 10:54 – 11:49PM
B. Parents confirm Shellie home at 11:49PM
C. Cell call incoming 12:53 – 12:56 incoming 3 minutes
D. Cell Call incoming 1:05 AM; 1:16 AM; 1:24 AM not answered
E. No out going calls to BB on her cell after 11:49 PM
Justice requests any input from our cadre of sleuths or any other scenarios or comments that could further our thinking on the HRT Bus drivers story.
Written by Clarke Kent
In the recorded conversation of BB on WS he reveals in post 4/29 a person names Pensfan asks BB when she rode her bike to his house the evening before she was murdered by a coward…(MF has told people that they had sex). What did you discuss with MF when you called him the evening before May was brutally murdered? (You/BB) mentioned talking to MF on the phone in post 429.
BB replies to Pensfan in his post #437 which is attached below. He starts his post by startling tell all “Well honestly that I didn’t know. Hmmmmm and thats news to me he didnt tell me that.” he continues “Well I guess Mary thought we was broken up that night until we made up when I came over later that night to her house but I have no idea what occurred with her and her ex MF but me an his conversation was about our argument we had he was there.”
What we know is there was 4 conversations between BB and MF just prior and immediately after BB learning of Shellie’s murder. When BB responds to Pensfan he tells us he had no idea Shellie had sex with MF and to my astonishment confirms that he was unaware they broke up even though he received the rings be returned to him from Shellie. Remember BB had possession of the rings Shellie cherished.
I have often reflected on the numerous comments BB wrote on WS and the Justice for Shellie blog/website. I have come to a conclusion that BB was using both WS and Justice for Shellie blog to advance his story. I strongly ask readers to evaluate all comments on both forums and note BB carefully introduces his bias slant on what information he conveys in his comments.
Are they planted to cover his story and account what happened? Did they ever reconcile since BB is the sole person who made that statement. Maybe BB visit was a prelude to his plan to pay her back.
There are so many comments and a careful reading will indicate clearly his slant of the reality of what really transpired including his receiving the call on his home telephone. Why it would give him the alibi of being at home.
Please note BB added post #438, 20 minutes after he posted #437 and it was only added to get the slant on the 1 am something on his home phone. See attachment # 438.
Written by Clarke Kent
Lois Layne and Clarke Kent met with BW in the Central Library. LL writes the attached comment on the interview. I had to make several small redactions however Lois Layne portrays what was said. Very little was learned as BW is very guarded and suspicious of people. Anonymous original contact Justice regarding a meth lab arrest of BW. Anon Source originally told me that with conversations with her sources BW may have been present at the party previous to Shellie’s murder. She related that BW is always on the brink of an emotional break down and lives every moment in serious fear for her life and terrified of MS2.
She was arrested on 11/07/14 and charged with a felony the first being manufacture of controlled substance case #GC14016636-00 and the second for Possession of Controlled substances #GD14016635-00. She was incarcerated for 45 days before she was released with a Nolle Prosequi – which means the Commonwealth was unwilling to prosecute. However if the statute of limitations have not run she could be re indicted and prosecuted again.
The only interest Justice had in following this arrest was because we believed CT and MS2 and LJP were involved in the meth lab and the VBPD would have a potential reason for cooperation for BW in exchange for vital information on Shellie’s murder and no charges however never materialized and the episode ended with no prosecution for anyone.
I found BW as a very unresponsive person who had no valuable information for us to hope for information that would lead to Shellie’s case being solved. Nothing of value was learned and I learned that BW had a child with MS2. I will quote exactly what BW told us about her and MS2. She said when she told MS2 she was pregnant his first response was “are you sure it’s mine?” Then he told her to do what she had to do but it wasn’t him problem. She then said shortly after finding out about the pregnancy, he went to Aruba for an extended period of time. He has never been a part of that child’s life and has only ever seen him a handful of times in his entire life.
Please read Lois Layne’s attachment that summarizes an interview that was not productive in our search for Justice for Shellie.
Written by Clarke Kent
She relates in a comment on post entitled “BB comments – Do They Hide His Agenda Of Creating A Ficticious Scenario?” posted July 22nd, 2017. She approaches her soul searching with “I thought of it this way how would each and everyone of us feel if it were our sons or daughters…being talked about.” (regarding Shellie’s murder.) I could take the same sentence and change a few words and I would be thinking about the exact opposite. Justice would prefer to soul search in a proactive way, so I thought of this way, how would each and every one of us feel if it were our sons or daughter that were brutally murdered and no one was talking about it almost 14 years later. So I would follow a more proactive avenue, one of doing, and taking the initiative and asking questions from day one. This is what the Carsons did, however they were not satisfied by the response from VBPD. They learned the reality that their daughter’s murder was not getting the attention and there was no positive leads leading to solving their daughter’s murder. They learned of some bungling by the LE and possible problems with the DNA.
When a group of students from Norfolk Academy approached the family with spirit and youthful excitement they were happy that the case might get more publicity and help. So the group known as the Students for Justice for Shellie took action and with a giant sign on Va Beach Blvd reintroduce the murder via a giant billboard. it’s a long story but they eventually moved on to college and graduate school. The bottom line is publicity and people come forward energized the adults who are still a part of today’s Justice for Shellie group.
We all can take different paths, Justice has taken a proactive approach and discusses all aspects of Shellie’s murder, while R who is respected prefers to urge others “that each one of you that post here really put your heart into what I have said and stop posting shut this down and let people move on and leave this to the real detectives and law enforcement officers.”
Maybe R’s approach is correct, however we Va Beach citizens have the right and passion to ask questions and talk to others. We still learn new information when we communicate with others.
R didn’t you speak to someone very recently and you learned what you considered was new valuable information according to you by communicating with another Va Beach citizen. Remember you sent me all the information.
My point is we learned by communicating with others and learned possible valuable information on Shellie’s murder. I prefer to stay active and keep asking questions.
R, we will miss you and wish you luck and good health.
Written by Clarke Kent
Justice has attached 3 comments by BB on WS. Post #431, 432 and 434. In Dec 2011 BB presents 3 comments dealing with his cooperation to help solve the murder of his girlfriend. As well as his guilt for not getting her the cigarettes and his consternation with the VBPD for not agressively pursuing the case. he tells us “ok imma say this and I don’t care if the cops see it….I think there being lazy on this case….seems like they don’e give a crap about it there taken all this information and throwing it aside obviously it says even the smallest anonymous tip could help they need to pursue that this case needs to be solved this animals need to be put down locked away seriously angers me that the justice system here is messed up beyond the max.”
Justice reminds readers to evaluate all BB comments with a critical view that everything he transmitted to us is his version and by repeating it over, and by repeating it over and over he slants it as almost facts. The cigarette issue is a perfect example. We know that Shellie from BB perspective called him after the reconciliation and told him she was going out to get cigarettes and it went to his house phone. We know from cell records that, that did not occur. BB reveals a story around his guilt for not getting her cigarettes, however he doesn’t make any effort to follow up in the morning. Very odd fora guy when he is trying to reconcile with his fiance that didn’t happen and he never returned her rings. Pretty puzzling. Maybe everything BB is telling us is information to create his own version of events. You be the judge.
Written by Clarke Kent
BB was asked a question on Justice for Shellie’s WS thread from McSpy and answer with a post #428. I will attach post #428 and post #429, both in December 2011. It was interesting how BB (CheddahB) answers a legitimate question was Shellie afraid of anyone? BB answers the question with “She was only afraid of dun. I have no clue of anyone else she didn’t shed light on anyones name except FB….that heartless dudes name? He doesn’t really tell us anything new however does mention Tim, a boy working at BKing who sent Shellie a love letter. He brings up CT, however he weaves in that he only recognized him via a picture Miranda showed him. He reveals he heard stories about CT, MH, LJP, etc. He includes his parents hearing stories of these guys just like half of Va Beach. Nothing new as we have heard hundreds of people telling us stories about CT and 4 guys almost like they themselves planted the bad boy image and kept it “popping up everywhere.” Nothing new but reheard hearsay that became public knowledge.
Now his other post #429 in which BB unsolicited presents his declaration of what transpired by introducing his story of what happened. His introducing of “Now if I may point out me and her had an argument that might that honestly truly sorted out. Here he is setting of tone of what he wants readers to believe; since it is his view since Shellie isn’t here to refute what really might have happened in their reconciliation and his point that everything was patched up and was according to him a happy ending to an argument between them . He sets the pattern with his view only. It is therefore very important to evaluate what facts we know as much of his storyline is solely coming from him. Part of my introducing his statements in his own words is because we must look at everything we learned and we are learning to come up with the truth. By looking at his statements we can put the puzzle together with our own logic and facts that we know. Again in this statement that was unsolicited he manages to put in his telephone was his house phone and he contradicts himself by telling us she said call me BB when you get home but he doesn’t. Why? Possible he wanted proof that he was home and that took the storyline of her calling him not the opposite. The telephone calls to his home phone, via her cell never happened and BB can’t explain this. He was adamant time after time that he recognized her telephone when he spoke to her and it was her cell.
Justice has so many statements from BB and I will share them as they can tell us what BB wants us to think. Shellie’s response will be represented by out critical evaluation of the actual truth.