Written by Clarke Kent
Justice has reviewed the comments by Moles and Sureluck that raised several issues pointed to our investigation. I will attempt to clarify me position on what issues were raised. With regard to Moles issue with the discovery of the body, Justice believes that it is still not clear as to who discovered Shellie’s body, because the official Incident report does not indicate the “R” – Reporting Person and only clouds the issue by not identifying PH as the reporting person. Sureluck on this issue states “Involved Other could mean anything really. It could also mean that there was simply a mistake in the report.” Sureluck continues “I think because of the severity of the crime simply putting him as a person wouldn’t be sufficient since he found a body and according to him attempted to care for her. However, I don’t think there’s much significance to this information.” Justice, however believes that there is significance since the incident Report was conduced 12 days later when the printed copy gives a date of 8/26/2005 10:32:39.
In other words the report wasn’t a contemporaneous report but one that he later input and was only official 12 days after the discovery. When Justice filed a Freedom of Information Act Request seeking the following “Documents related to police being notified of a body at Kings Grant Circle. Any recording or written document that notified police of a possible crime. All incident reports of the notification as well as information on who reported the possible crime and person or persons at the site when police arrived at the scene. All documents related to the other departments that were notified and responded to the scene.” the VBPD response was “In response to your request regarding the report you referenced and the material requested, the material is criminal investigation information or material. As such, it is exempted from disclosure, at our discretion under Section 2.2-3706 (A) (2) (a) of the Code of Virginia (Freedom of Information Act). It is the policy of this office to not release criminal investigative information or material without a Subpoena.”
The bottom line for me is why is the VBPD so closed to sharing public information that is supposed to be available to all Va beach citizens. Now they would allow us to look at that was requested and seek a subpoena. this is not what the Freedom of Information Act is about, however that is for a discussion at another date. What is being hidden?? the significance means truth.
Surelock aso brings up the information collected on PH from Coworker, gigi, Friendly Neighbor. Since Clarke Kent discovered this information on the website/blog it indicates that the blog is a great magnet for people to learn and also contribute. Since I spoke directly to all these people, I can categorically states that they are believable and I value their contributions.
Sureluck the issue concerning knocking on the vacant house door, I can state in our interview with PH he states he went there first came back to the body and then called. He also stated the ems were there prior to VBPD who he revealed were at a location on Little Neck Rd and New Castle and it was him who directed them to the New Castle location on Kings Grant where Shellie’s body was discovered.
Justice also agrees with Sureluck that SH knows her husband and could be helpful to le, however she is protecting her family and by extension, PH. She probably knows what type of a guy she married as he was out of the house shortly after Shellie’s murder. She would have circumstantial evidence and that could support other evidence present at the trial. She however will protect herself and her family first pushing the Carson family down on her list of to do list. We agree that her cooperation would certainly help the VBPD to take further interest in Shellie’s case. Moles also concludes that “Her (SH) concern and empathy for Shellie and her family may be enough to help if she can.”
Moles questions the issue of the vacant house and states “Don’t forget the home of the door he knocked on was under construction and empty. Would love to know who had the keys?” Moles also asks questions about damage to the house, etc. Justice reveals in an interview posted as “Justice on Vacant House at the Murder Site“‘ dated Feb 21, 2012 that he spoke to the owner Jimmy C and reveals that the was a person who purchased the house and was getting it ready for his kids to start school in a few weeks. He answered all my questions including his experience with the VBPD. He was a legitimate family man working with another to fix his new purchased home and make it habitable for his family. He did reveal that the VBPD request that they remove a large shrub from his corner on New Castle and Kings Grant Circle. I urge you to read this post as Justice believes this house had no involvement in Shellie’s murder.